Whether you’re designing your own bridesmaid proposal bundle box with a bunch of small, affordable items or want a buy a single gift that’s a bit pricier (like this custom acrylic entertaining set) — or buy a pre-made bridesmaid proposal gift, we have a ton of options for you to choose from that are all highly rated. From a sweet bridesmaid proposal breakable chocolate heart, These unique bridesmaid proposal gifts will leave a lasting impression on your friend group and show them truly how much they mean to you. Here at Parade.com, we’re all about sharing products we love with our audience. When you make a purchase on an item seen on this page, we may earn a commission, however, all picks are independently chosen unless otherwise mentioned.
25 Best Bridesmaid Proposal Gifts
1. Custom Jewelry Box, $21.21 on Etsy
This handmade, durable jewelry box can be customized with your bridesmaid’s initials and is big enough to hold all her favorite keepsakes like a bracelet, earrings, necklace, ring, watch and more. The cute monogrammed jewelry case from Etsy comes in pastel colors to match your wedding vibes whether it’s pink, blue, beige, green or purple. Custom Jewelry Box, $21.21 on Etsy
2. Modern Script Sage Green Bridesmaid Proposal Gift Waiter’s Corkscrew, $15.78 at Zazzle
For the bridal party that loves to party, buy them all a custom wine opener with their name from Zazzle. Designed with a stainless steel foil cutter blade, bottle cap opener and ergonomic plastic handle, this bridesmaid gift will come in handy on the bachelorette trip! Modern Script Sage Green Bridesmaid Proposal Gift Waiter’s Corkscrew, $15.78 at Zazzle
3. Bespoke Plate Adjustable Bracelet Gold, $60 at Gorjana
Jewelry is always a safe option when you’re popping the question with your bridesmaids. Head over to Gorjana to buy this classic bespoke plate adjustable bracelet in gold for $60. Engraving is no extra charge! Bespoke Plate Adjustable Bracelet Gold, $60 at Gorjana
4. Bridesmaid Proposal Hair Tie Favor, $2.75+ on Etsy
If your bridal party is on the larger side, you should check out these bridesmaid proposal hair tie favors for under $5 on Etsy. We love the whimsical packaging that says “Will you help me tie the knot? I can’t say ‘I Do’ without you!” Bridesmaid Proposal Hair Tie Favor, $2.75+ on Etsy
5. “Be My Bridesmaid?” Eye Mask, $50 at Hill House Home
Head to Hill House Home to buy the coziest bridesmaid proposal gift ever! The “Be My Bridesmaid?” Eye Mask is made of 100% silk so it’s not only luxurious, but super functional for a good night’s sleep. “Be My Bridesmaid?” Eye Mask, $50 at Hill House Home
6. Pinch Provisions Be My Bridesmaid Kit, $22 at REVOLVE
Pinch Provisions Be My Bridesmaid Kit includes 24 essentials she can use on your wedding day including bobby pins, mirror, pain reliever, emery board, clear nail polish, extra wedding bands, mini blotting tissue and so much more. Pinch Provisions Be My Bridesmaid Kit, $22 at REVOLVE
7. Bridesmaid Garment Bag, $44 on Etsy
It’s always a good idea to get your bridesmaids a gift they can use, which is why we included this personalized garment bag in our bridesmaid proposal gift round-up. If your wedding is a destination wedding, this bridesmaid proposal gift is a must! Bridesmaid Garment Bag, $44 on Etsy
9. Personalized Luggage Tag, $3.99 on Etsy
Make your bridesmaids travel in style with this affordable, personalized luggage tag in acrylic for $3.99 on Etsy. This bridesmaid proposal gift is such a low price that you can use it as an add-on if you’re making your own goody bag. Personalized Luggage Tag, $3.99 on Etsy
10. Engrave Your Bottle! Casamigos Tequila Blanco, $69 at Personal Wine
Celebrate with your bridesmaids with a shot of booze and gift them this customizable Casamigos Tequila Blanco Bottle. Engrave the bottle for an extra $30 charge and really make a statement! Note: Your custom message will be engraved below the original front label and filled with an elegant golden inlay. Engrave Your Bottle! Casamigos Tequila Blanco, $69 at Personal Wine
12. Little Words Project Custom Bridesmaid Bracelet, $25 at Little Words Project
Little Words Project has the trendiest custom beaded bracelets, so get your besties in your bridal party this bridesmaid beaded bracelet. She can stack it with all her other bracelets and rep your bridal squad with style. Little Words Project Custom Bridesmaid Bracelet, $25 at Little Words Project
13. Will you be my Bridesmaid Minimalist Modern Photo Plaque, $20 at Zazzle
Picture frames are the perfect home decor accent! Surprise your bridesmaid with this sentimental 5 x 7 photo plaque and place a sweet picture of you and her inside. Will you be my Bridesmaid Minimalist Modern Photo Plaque, $20 at Zazzle
14. Luxury Personalized Bridesmaid Tote Bag, $49 on Etsy
Whether you’re composing your own bridesmaid gift package or want a stand-alone bridesmaid proposal gift, this luxury personalized bridesmaid tote bag for a price-point of $49 is a win. “The quality of the Totes were absolutely perfect,” says a 5-star reviewer on Etsy. “The ladies absolutely loved them!” Luxury Personalized Bridesmaid Tote Bag, $49 on Etsy
15. Collar Monogram Sweatshirt, $38 on Etsy
It’s officially the fall season, so it’s the best time to buy sweatshirts for your bridesmaids if you have an upcoming wedding. This Collar Monogram Sweatshirt is understated and minimalistic, yet super trendy right now. Have your each of bridesmaids rock this fashionable layer all season long after you ask her to be in your bridal party. Collar Monogram Sweatshirt, $38 on Etsy
16. To My Bridesmaid Engraved Mirrored Jewelry Box-Large, $45.49 at Personalization Mall
This large mirrored jewelry box should cost more than $45.59, especially the fact that it’s personalized! Show your bridesmaid how much you truly care by purchasing this luxurious engraved jewelry box that measures a generous 9.5" W x 7.5" D x 4.75" H. Personalization Mall has express ship options available, too, if you’re in a jam. To My Bridesmaid Engraved Mirrored Jewelry Box-Large, $45.49 at Personalization Mall
17. Bridesmaid Proposal Kit—Bridesmaids 2.0, $109 at Homesick
Up next, another pre-made bridesmaid proposal kit for just over $100 is available at Homesick. Included in this bridesmaid proposal party package is a candle, three face masks, a Corksicle stemless flute and 14K gold plated huggies. Bridesmaid Proposal Kit - Bridesmaids 2.0, $109 at Homesick
18. Personalized Claw Clip, $16 on Etsy
So we are totally obsessed with claw clips, but these personalized hair clips take it to the next level! Get your bridesmaids’ name made on this acetate hair accessory in the color combo of your choice for as low as $16 on Etsy. Personalized Claw Clip, $16 on Etsy
19. Acrylic Entertaining Gift Set, $173 at Mark & Graham
After your bridesmaids receive this monogrammed acrylic entertaining gift set, they will want to post their bridesmaid proposal on Instagram to show it off! This entertaining set includes one large etched acrylic tray, one acrylic pitcher and four acrylic stemless wine glasses—perfect for entertaining indoors or outdoors all year long. Acrylic Entertaining Gift Set, $173 at Mark & Graham
20. Women’s I Do and I Do Crew Slide Slipper, $16 at Dearfoams
You can never have enough slippers! Ask your besties to be in your bridal party by buying these fitting Dreamfoams slippers that are on sale. These fuzzy slide slippers come in 5 colors in women’s sizes S - XL. Women’s I Do and I Do Crew Slide Slipper, $16 at Dearfoams
21. Bridesmaid Proposal Hanging Rose with Stand Gift, $35.04 on Etsy
Opt for a dainty hanging rose that comes with a stand so your bridesmaid can put it on display in her home. The long-lasting preserved roses are available in different color options and last up to a year. Bridesmaid Proposal Hanging Rose with Stand Gift, $35.04 on Etsy
22. “Will You?” Cacti Garden, $30 at Lula’s Garden
Ask your friend to be your bridesmaid by buying this adorable baby cactus she can put on display. The succulent arrives in a pretty designed planter gift box (with the question “Will You” printed on the top) to get her pumped about the big news! “Will You?” Cacti Garden, $30 at Lula’s Garden
23. Can’t Say I Do Without You, $60 at Knack
Next, we’re highlighting this $60 gift set you can mail to all your bridesmaids that has bath bombs, a Voluspa Sparkling Rose candle and trendy matches in a jar. She will feel so appreciated to be in your bridal party when she sees all of these fabulous goodies. Can’t Say I Do Without You, $60 at Knack
24. Rosé All Day Earrings, $48 at Baublebar
Asking your girls to be a part of your crew is a big celebration, which is why these fun Rosè All Day Earrings are one of our favorite picks for bridesmaid gifts. Baublebar always has cute costume jewelry but these are one of our faves. Rosé All Day Earrings, $48 at Baublebar
25. Bridesmaid Proposal Breakable Chocolate Heart, $39.60 on Etsy
Show them how sweet it’s going to be being a part of your bride squad by shopping this bridesmaid proposal breakable chocolate heart on Etsy. This is definitely a stand-out gift compared to other typical bridesmaid proposal gifts — and it’s a fun activity that builds up the suspense! Bridesmaid Proposal Breakable Chocolate Heart, $39.60 on Etsy Up next, check out 125 romantic love quotes!
